If you live in New York, you know a thing or two about pizza. New Yorkers are famous for their pizza. Mineola has its share of places to grab a great pizza pie. Follow us to see where to get the best pie in the city of Mineola or close-by.

Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria Restaurant

This is not your average pizza joint. Yes, they have great pizza, but they have tons of other authentic Italian foods on the menu. They have a good reputation for seafood. The owner is a hands-on kind of guy and it shows. Good service, good food, what’s not to love?

MaMa Gina’s

This is the perfect New York pizza. The crust is crisp and the sauce is perfect and it makes for a good Italian pizza. Whether you are looking for a pie to take home for dinner or a dozen for a business meeting, you will get them fresh and hot. Did I mention the sauce? Yum!

Luigi’s Pizzeria

Luigi’s makes a great pizza, and they have other foods so the whole crew can be happy. The chicken is good too! You can get a whole pizza or have a custom slice with your favorite toppings. Luigi’s was voted in the top 5 pizza places in Long Island.

Barosa’s Pizza

This is a quaint little place. It is neat and clean but not too fancy. But none of that matters the minute you taste their food. Very good pizza and a good selection of foods. They have authentic Italian desserts that are perfect.

Spaghettini Trattoria

This is a traditional Italian restaurant. Yes, they serve pizza and it is good Italian pizza, New York style. But they have other foods. Enjoy sandwiches and salads too. The place is clean and the service is top notch.

Louie’s Pizzeria

Louie’s Pizzeria is in Carle Place, just a little up the road. But it is worth the extra few minutes to get there. They will take reservations and the service is good. The food is delicious and it is all authentic. They will go out of their way to make your experience pleasant.

MaMa Theresa’s Pizzeria

MaMa Theresa’s has been around for years. That’s because they know how to make some good food. They have regular customers who will eat nowhere else when they want Italian. MaMa Theresa’s will become like part of your family.

Maggiano’s Little Italy

This establishment is an upper scale Italian restaurant. However, they make such a perfect pizza, we could not leave them off our favorites. Yes, they have fine Italian dishes, served by caring staff. But the perfectly blended sauce and melted mozzarella and roasted tomatoes make the pizza fantastic. Make reservations if you don’t want to wait. They get pretty busy on the weekends, but you will soon know why. It is really great food.

There are other places on Long Island to get pizza. Pizza is a staple food in New York. But if you want the best, you’ve got a good list to start working through. One thing is for sure, you will not go home hungry.